Custom font not working using CSS code

Site URL: http://multiplestoriespodcast.com

Hi,

I am trying to add a custom font to my website. This is the code I am using:

@font-face { 
font-family: 'Cream';
src: url(https://static1.squarespace.com/static/5fc85217dac71e5b78803919/t/5fd3564d590d9171f96aad55/1607685710583/Cream+Peach.otf)
}
h1 {
font-family: 'Cream';
}
h2 {
font-family: 'Cream';
}
p {
font-family: 'Cream';
}

This just appears on my site as Times New Roman. I  have tried an OTF file and a TTF file in both Google Chrome and Microsoft Edge. Could it be the actual font type? Please help!

Edit: I have tried another computer that still does not appear to work. I can see that the CSS editor is clearly changing font but not to anything close to my actual font. Please help I am very confused.

Assuming the code works, what should the heading look like?