Trying to move an item from a second (archive) store page back to the main store

I created a second "store" to archive items that are sold out but that I don't want to delete entirely in case I bring them back or because I want the one of a kind items for people to see.

Anyway... I'm trying to move an item from one store to the other, and I click through and click move and then the item just disappears entirely. I can find it under All in my archive if I search for it, but otherwise it's not there. The page is there but it's not showing up on the page if that makes sense. I tried duplicating the page and moving it but that doesn't work either. 

Anyone else having this problem? I've tried on Chrome, Microsoft and Firefox and in the iOS app. Nothing works. 

Thanks!