Error message when connecting to GoDaddy?

Hi, everybody- I'm trying to connect a new squarespace site to a GoDaddy domain, and get the message below after completing the setup.

When i check godaddy, the DNS settings look like they've been changed to the required ones for squarespace (see second attached image) , but the domains do not show up under my Domains in Squarespace settings for that site. 

Any ideas what the problem is? I've had to deal with this in the past on another site but can't remember what the solution was.

Thanks!

EDIT: never mind, i figured it out!