Cloudflare domain connection issue

Site URL: https://www.sparrowtheapp.com/

@colin.irwin or anyone - I would really appreciate your help.

I bought a domain on CloudFlare: https://sparrowstartup.com/

I am now trying to connect my SquareSpace account to it. And it's not working. I've followed the guide for updating the DNS on SquareSpace but the DNS statuses on SquareSpace + the actual CNAMES keep randomly changing their status from red to green and back. Please see images below.

The DNS settings right now are NOT proxied on CloudFlare. Yet I'm still having this issue. Please help me fix this.

Both domains are now going to your squarespace site.