Best Membership Plugin?

Hi!  Could anyone please recommend the best integrating Gated Content / Digital Membership PlugIn?  I am currently using Memberspace and feel like the integration is not as tight as I'd like.  I have to turn off Customer Log In functionality in order for it to work meaning that my non-members can't log into the site which sucks.  Also, I have more physical subscriptions than digital only subscriptions right now and intend to keep growing that way.  Lastly, my physical subscriptions include access to a gated section of my site.  I'm really just looking for a solution that integrates better with Squarespace and Shipstation as I scale.  I would appreciate any other membership sites or gated portal plug ins you guys use that you love.  

Thank you!!

Hey @Shereen! I'm with Memberstack and we support a lot of folks using Squarespace with a user login or membership payment use-case. Would love to get your feedback on our tool if you're open to giving it a try 😄

I have used both MemberSpace and MemberStack.  Here are my thoughts: https://christyprice.com/squarespace-tips-tricks/members-area-squarespace-website

Hey, @Shereen!

If you are still looking for an alternative, Squarespace has recently released a new feature called Member Areas. You can read more about it here:

Getting started with Member Areas

Hope this helps!